The Spark: Where It Started

A direct-to-consumer health brand had built a loyal following over the years — but repeat purchases were in steady decline. Customer acquisition remained strong, but something was quietly eroding on the back end.

The issue wasn’t product. It was the experience between purchases.

“We were measuring NPS, but not really learning from it. People liked the product — they just didn’t come back.” — CX Lead

That prompted a bigger question: what moments in the journey were silently causing drop-off?

The Pilot Approach: Digging Deeper

We launched a pilot designed to surface the pain points that weren’t loud — but were costly. This meant zooming in on key transition moments across the journey, and layering in behavioral and emotional data.

The pilot included:

  • A journey mapping sprint using real customer data and support logs
  • Drop-off analysis across the digital funnel and post-purchase flows
  • Micro-surveys embedded at key moments to capture in-the-moment sentiment
  • Call and chat transcript reviews to identify patterns in frustration or confusion
  • Behavioral tagging across touchpoints to reveal friction trends

Pilot stats:

  • Identified a 19% increase in churn when delivery communications were unclear or delayed
  • Reduced support tickets related to order tracking by 34% within 60 days
  • Found that 41% of customers who experienced confusion post-purchase never completed a second order

This insight reframed the problem: satisfaction wasn’t about one great moment — it was about removing the small, invisible frictions.

The Inflection Point: Insight to Opportunity

The “aha” moment came when we tracked feedback from a seemingly minor moment: the confirmation email. Customers consistently mentioned uncertainty about what came next, what to expect, or who to contact.

The fix wasn’t flashy — it was clarity.

By redesigning the post-purchase flow with clear language, touchpoint transparency, and emotionally intelligent messaging, the team saw a measurable boost in customer satisfaction scores and second-order rates.

Experience became the differentiator.

From Pilot to Use Case: A Repeatable Model

This body of work evolved into a core use case:
Identifying and addressing pain points in customer journeys to improve the overall customer experience and satisfaction.

We helped the team turn their insights into long-term capability by:

  • Building a real-time CX dashboard to flag drop-off zones and response lags
  • Designing a behaviorally-informed journey map to guide experience strategy
  • Integrating automated feedback prompts into key transition points
  • Establishing a cross-functional CX squad to rapidly respond to journey issues
  • Creating a CX knowledge base of common frictions and tested solutions

Key behavioral trends identified:

  • Customers were more tolerant of delays if expectations were clearly managed upfront
  • The emotional tone of communication impacted perceived product value, even when logistics stayed the same
  • Confusion in early onboarding was a leading indicator of future disengagement
  • Trust was built not through perfection, but through proactive transparency

Why It Matters

Customer experience isn’t just a feel-good metric — it’s a business driver. When organizations remove friction from the journey, they reduce churn, increase loyalty, and earn the kind of word-of-mouth you can’t buy.

Here’s what powered the impact in this use case — and what other teams can build on:

  • Customer journey mapping tied to behavioral data and emotional checkpoints
  • Drop-off and friction point analysis through quantitative and qualitative lenses
  • Real-time sentiment tracking through micro-surveys and clickstream tools
  • Emotional tone testing across confirmation, onboarding, and support messaging
  • Voice-of-the-customer analysis via call and chat reviews
  • Behavioral segmentation to match experience flows with customer mindsets
  • Cross-functional CX squads for rapid action
  • Experience prototyping to test micro-adjustments before scaling
  • Post-interaction feedback loops embedded into CRM and support tools
  • Metrics that tie CX to retention and repeat purchase rates

Fixing the journey doesn’t always require a reinvention — just the discipline to look, listen, and respond.


Discover more from Blue Monarch Group

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Stay Updated with the Latest from the BMG!

From thought-provoking discussions to interactive workshops and labs, our programs showcase the latest insights and strategies in human behavior and marketing.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn, connect, and grow with us!

Behavioral Insight You Can Practice in Real Time

Short-format, high-impact sessions where teams learn to design for trust, clarity, and change—one behavioral challenge at a time.

Go Deeper Than Insight—Build the Strategy That Shifts Behavior

Multi-phase programs built to solve your most critical challenges using behavioral research, reframing, and high-impact system design.

Book Club for Business Leaders

Unlock new insights and connect with fellow senior leaders in our exclusive book club. Explore the depths of human behavior, share perspectives, and drive meaningful change in your specialties.

Shaping Perspectives in the Changing Hearts and Minds Series

Join us for an enlightening series exploring the intricacies of human behavior and the transformative power of mindset and emotions. In each session, we'll delve into thought-provoking topics, share expert insights, and discuss practical strategies for driving change.

Explore Human Behavior

Dive into the depths of human behavior and uncover transformative insights with BMG's Discovery Lab. Join us as we explore innovative strategies, spark dynamic discussions, and drive forward-thinking solutions.

Fuel Future Evolution

Empower your organization to thrive in a rapidly changing world with BMG's Innovation Lab. Discover cutting-edge strategies, collaborate with industry pioneers, and revolutionize your approach to innovation

Butterfly Effect

Sign up for the insights. Keep you with the times!